by SandyK » Thu May 15, 2008 9:33 am
What I find odd is that it sounds like the family is having allergies since they moved into this house. And that there are at least two members of the family suffering from them. The first thing that comes to my mind is mold. Have they investigated to see if mold could be the problem? Normally the Seattle area is pretty good for allergies in general, but in the spring we get ragweed, and mold can be a problem year round but especially in the winter when our houses are are closed up...then spring comes and we go outside and get hit with the ragweed. Ragweed is everywhere, pretty much, but mold is more common in wet climates like ours. However, it can be addressed within the home, in most cases, which would negate the need to move (I assume however, that this possibility has been explored).
If you want to protect your credit, and if you want to be able to buy a home again in the near future, then it's important to at least make a good faith effort to live up to the obligations that you enter into with a lender. I would not recommend to stop making payments before entering into a discussion regarding short sale or other options. Some lenders may not be willing to talk about it but I think it's outdated information to automatically assume that lenders aren't willing to talk. A lot has changed in the last 6 to 12 months and one of the things that has changed is that banks are no longer under the impression that they will get more out of the house by foreclosing than by working out an agreement with a borrower. Some still won't, but it's not universally true that you won't get anywhere. Ask S-Crow if you don't believe me, but short sales ARE happening and are becoming more common.
In a case like this, there are options but it's important to work from a place of good faith if you want future lenders to see you as a good risk. I think how borrowers handle themselves now is going to have a big impact on their ability to buy a home in the future. Yes, if you do a short sale, or any variation on that theme, your credit will take a hit but how big of a hit depends on how you work it out. If the home is able to be sold short (which depending on the loan servicer, this is a possibility), it's possible to work out a payment on the deficiency and maybe rent for a couple of years until that is paid off. As folks on this board are always pointing out, renting is not the end of the world and in some cases is the best option. Two years, or even five years, is not forever.
There are lots of ways to handle this, but almost all of them require talking to your lender about the situation and working from a place of wanting to make good on your obligations. And, I think we would all do well to remember that a mortgage IS an obligation--if you walk away from that obligation, the bank is legally entitled to go after you with all the tools at their disposal.
Also, regarding costs of sale, there are TONS of real estate companies that charge less than 6%. HelpUSell, MLS4Owners and Redfin are just a few. Many agents also take on cases like this to help out homeowners in need. And there is always the straight FSBO route, which, if the house is priced really well, can work.
The main thing is that you can't approach a situation like this from a position of hopelessness or it will always appear that you have fewer options than is the case. I don't mean to say that this is the case here, more that for anyone reading this thread, it's important to explore all the alternatives and not to discount any of them just because you heard somewhere that the option isn't available.