Seattle Bubble

News & discussion about real estate & the housing bubble in the Seattle area.

Seattle Bubble - News & discussion about real estate & the housing bubble in the Seattle area.

Entries Tagged as 'reporting_roundup'

October Reporting Roundup: Happy Fun Tax Credit Party Time!

By The Tim on November 6th, 2009 at 8:00 AM · 45 Comments

Time for the monthly reporting roundup, where I read all the local paper rehashes of the NWMLS press release so you don’t have to.

Here’s a link to this month’s NWMLS press release: Tax credit spurs big surge in Western Washington home sales

Before we get into the roundup, I’d like to take a moment to quote an excerpt from the monthly NWMLS data post from May, which was titled Huge Gap Opening Between Pending and Closed Sales (a subject that I first brought to your attention in August of last year).

The disconnect between pending sales and closed sales grows ever larger. … Something is becoming extremely fishy about the pending sales data.

…it is good to keep in mind when you start reading news reports in the coming weeks about the market supposedly picking back up. It’s an illusion.

Here’s a graphical representation of the 2009 sales illusion:

2009 Pending and Closed King Co. SFH Sales

Pending sales peaked at 2,447 in June, while so far closed sales have not made it higher than 1,758—a nearly 30% discrepancy. So far this year there have been at total of 20,025 pending SFH sales in King County, but only 12,986 actual closed sales. In other words, more than a third (35%) of pending sales have yet to materialize into closed sales. That difference is typically well under 10%.

Find me a newspaper that reported this growing issue last August.

Click below for this month’s roundup of gawking at the tax credit.

[Read more →]

→ 45 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Reporting Roundup Flashback: September 2007

By The Tim on October 9th, 2009 at 9:00 AM · 33 Comments

Let’s look back a couple years to see what local real estate agents were saying a few months after the price peak in Seattle, and about a year into the housing decline across most of the rest of the country. Here’s a selection of choice quotes from some October 2007 articles. Note that local home prices are down roughly 15% ($60,000 on a $400,000 home) in the two years since these articles were published.

NWMLS press release, October 5, 2007:

Trying to time the market is “a fool’s game,” remarked one MLS director. “If you are buying a home to live in for more than three years, then buy the one you love, not the one that you can save $25,000 on,” advises Matt Deasy, general manager at Windermere Real Estate/East Inc. in Bellevue.

J. Lennox Scott, chairman and CEO of John L. Scott Real Estate said now is “an ideal time for buyers.”

“The time is right for buyers on the sidelines to step forward. They have many more home choices now than in the past few years,” observed [Windermere broker] Marcie Maxwell.

Seattle P-I, October 5, 2007:

One month of lower prices doesn’t mean much, said Glenn Crellin, director of the Washington Center for Real Estate Research at Washington State University.

“I think it is suggestive that there is some real softness in the (Seattle) market,” he said. “But at the same time, I think we’ve got a more resilient housing market than in many parts of the country.”

Matthew Gardner, a Seattle land-use economist who works with developers, does not put much weight on the Seattle median-home price, particularly because it excludes most sales of new condos, he said Friday.

Actually, year-to-year increases of about 4 percent in the median price across King County and the 19 counties in the listing service were higher than Gardner anticipated, he said. He expects a leveling off — with increases of roughly 3 percent — for a couple of years.

“We need to get through this backlog of inventory,” he said. “Also, we need to start allowing time for wages to catch up.”

Tacoma News Tribune, October 6, 2007:

Agents on Friday, however, largely portrayed Pierce County’s one-month price decline as more anomaly than trend and what’s to be expected in a market normalizing after the boom years of 2004 and 2005.

Buyers shouldn’t view one month of lower prices as a sign that more are on the way, said Bill Riley, owner of Gateway Real Estate. Riley is vice president-elect of the Washington Realtors, which plans to launch a campaign this month encouraging buyers to purchase now rather than wait.

“This is not a start of a decline. We’ve never seen a decline in such a strong fundamental market,” he said, pointing to expected job growth…

Everett Herald, October 6, 2007:

“It looks like the market has kind of taken a deep breath and just corrected itself a little bit,” said Nathan Gorton of the Snohomish County Camano Board of Realtors.

“It’s a good time to be a buyer right now.” … “I talk to a lot of buyers’ agents whose customers are saying they just want to sit back right now because they don’t think it’s a good time to buy a home,” he said. “They think, ‘Oh my gosh, the market is falling apart.’ Nothing could be further from the truth.”

For comparison, here were my comments about these stories at the time:

It will be interesting to watch the increasingly ridiculous gyrations of local real estate salespeople as the market continues its downward path, and they come up with more and more outrageous statements that fly in the face of reality. It looks like the bubble deflation show has finally rolled into town.

Indeed it has been an entertaining show, and trust me; it ain’t over yet.

→ 33 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , ,

September Reporting Roundup: Get your SURGE RALLY on!

By The Tim on October 6th, 2009 at 12:48 PM · 88 Comments

Time for the monthly reporting roundup, where I read all the local paper rehashes of the NWMLS press release so you don’t have to.

First up, an excerpt from the NWMLS press release itself: Northwest MLS brokers agree "there’s a lot to be optimistic about"

“There’s a lot to be optimistic about,” according to one director of the Northwest Multiple Listing Service upon reviewing summary statistics for September’s housing activity. The report shows a big jump in pending sales compared to a year ago (up almost 27 percent), continued drops in inventory (down 17.7 percent versus a year ago) and brisk demand for homes at the lower end of the price spectrum.

Joe Spencer, president and COO of John L. Scott Real Estate, estimates up to 10 percent of pending sales do not close because they’re caught in the short sale cycle. Still, he comments, “There is a lot to be optimistic about.” He cites interest rates that are now in the high four percents as bordering “on being epic” and the federal tax credit as stimulants to the market.

Activity at open houses is reported to be brisk in many areas…

Sweet! The return of the ever-popular “open house traffic” metric of market health. I love it. Also classic is the heavy focus on the pending sales stat, which has been rendered practically meaningless in the past year. FYI, that 10% estimate is way too low. I’d put it around 20-25%.

Anyway, click below to read the rest of this month’s reporting roundup, in which the incredible surge and uplifting rally is detailed by the enthusiastic local press corps.

[Read more →]

→ 88 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

August Reporting Roundup: Recovery Party Time!

By The Tim on September 7th, 2009 at 6:00 AM · 48 Comments

Thanks to PAX and the holiday weekend, our regular schedule is all messed up. So here’s the reporting roundup a couple days late.

First up, an excerpt from the NWMLS press release: Northwest MLS brokers report brisk activity, multiple offers, "irrational delays" by lenders

Pending sales around Western Washington during August jumped nearly 21 percent from a year ago and inventory dropped more than 18 percent, according to new figures from Northwest Multiple Listing Service. MLS member-brokers say those indicators, along with signs of stabilizing prices, set the stage for brisk activity in the next few months as first-time buyers try to take advantage of the Nov. 30 deadline for tax credits.

“The typical August cool down in the market did not happen this year,” observed NWMLS director Kathy Estey, managing broker at John L. Scott’s office in downtown Bellevue. She said agents are busy with both first-time and move-up buyers and they’re reporting multiple offers on homes priced up to $700,000.

Brokers reported 7,539 pending sales (offers made and accepted but not yet closed) for August, up 20.7 percent from a year ago. That volume outgained July’s total by 260 transactions.

In the four-county Puget Sound region, pending sales of single family homes and condominiums (combined) surged 25.7 percent from a year ago.

I’m only going to say this once in this post, since I get tired of repeating myself. The “pending sales” statistic published by the NWMLS has become virtually useless. It has of little to no use in reliably predicting actual closed sales volume this year.

That said, given that the NWMLS led off their press release with the big headline pending sales nonsense, it is (sadly) no surprise that a number of lazy local media outlets dutifuly repeated their breathless claims.

Read on to find out which local press outlets were basically just press release rehash factories this month, and which ones spent some time to do some actual reporting.

[Read more →]

→ 48 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

July Reporting Roundup: Sales are Up, Up, UP!

By The Tim on August 6th, 2009 at 2:45 PM · 31 Comments

For some reason, the NWMLS press release still has not been posted to their public site yet.

[Update: Here's a link to the press release on NWMLS.com: Northwest MLS brokers say housing market is recovering, but still "spongy". My favorite part is "July's unseasonably hot weather curtailed activity for several showings and open houses, as brokers and agents said buyers and sellers postponed tours, saying it was just too hot." "Several" people may have delayed their home shopping by a few days, and that's even worth mentioning? Wow.]

Before we get into this month’s news reports crowing about the increase in sales, here’s a little chart that shows the time between when pending sales went negative year-over-year and when the median price went negative year-over-year.

King County SFH Pending Sales and Median Price YOY Changes

Pending sales had been negative for over two years before prices began to fall. Keep that in mind when you hear claims that a few months of year-over-year positive sales data is allegedly a sign that prices will stabilize in the short term. Not likely.

Here’s another chart, this one showing the year-to-date change in the median price, both in 2008 and 2009:

King Co. Year-to-Date SFH Price Change

Does the fact that prices have risen from their March low indicate price drops are over? Probably not.

Read on for this month’s reporting roundup from the Times, P-I, Herald, News-Tribune, and Olympian.

[Read more →]

→ 31 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

June Reporting Roundup: Muted Enthusiasm for Increasing Sales

By The Tim on July 7th, 2009 at 10:49 AM · 37 Comments

With sales skyrocketing to a massive four percent gain over last year and median prices shooting through the roof, the housing market recovery is on, and it’s a race to report it. Let’s check in with the local news outlets to see who had the most sensational write-up this month.

First up, the NWMLS press release that accompanied yesterday’s numbers: "Aware and prepared buyers" help boost Western Washington home sales during June

“Encouraging” seemed to be a common response from brokers upon reviewing the June activity summaries from Northwest Multiple Listing Service. The report shows inventory continues to shrink, pending sales increased more than 19.5 percent from a year ago, and median prices system-wide are up 4.4 percent since January.

“The positive movement in our real estate market year over year is really very encouraging,” remarked Ron G. Sparks, managing vice president of Coldwell Banker Bain. Compared to 12 months ago, the Puget Sound region has nearly 7,000 fewer homes listed for sale, and nearly 1,200 more homes under contract, he noted, adding, “In anyone’s book, that’s substantial improvement.”

J. Lennox Scott, chairman and CEO of John L. Scott Real Estate, echoed those comments. “It’s encouraging to see that pending sales are at their highest since the credit bubble burst nearly two years ago,” he stated. While the median home price is down approximately 10 percent from a year ago, median prices have flattened over the past seven to nine months, he noted. “This is an indication that the $8,000 tax credit is working and the market has reactivated itself in the more affordable and mid price ranges,” Scott believes.

“There is a definite upsurge in sales activity, from a pending sales perspective and a “lookers becoming buyers” perspective,” observed NWMLS director Dick Beeson. Agents are reinvigorated that buyers can and will make decisions more today than any other time over the past 12 months, according to Beeson, the broker at Windermere Real Estate/Commencement Associates in Tacoma.

Beeson believes mortgage rates remaining low, declining inventories, and the recent stretch of warm, dry weather helped spur some buyers to act.

This month’s release is conspicuously lacking in the bottom calls and “buy now or you’ll be sorry” sentiment that has permeated previous NWMLS publications. They almost seem to have become less certain of immenent recovery, even as the sales finally begin to pick up. Could they perhaps be looking at the bigger picture and realizing that even once the bottom is in, the market is likely to roll along the bottom for years?

Or maybe I’m just reading too much into it.

Before we get into this month’s news reports, here’s a quick graphical representation of how far off closed sales are from pending sales so far this year:

King County SFH Pending & Closed Sales

The April to June rise in closed sales actually looks rather similar to the February to April rise in pendings. Pendings rose 67% from February to April, and closed sales rose 65% from April to June. Interesting, for sure.

If the pattern holds for the next two months with the 16% pending rise from April to June carrying over into closed sales from June to August, August will see roughly 1,900 closed sales (a 25% YOY increase). That feels a little higher than I’d expect to see, but I certainly wouldn’t put it outside the realm of possibility.

Read on for this month’s reporting roundup from the Times, P-I, Herald, News-Tribune, and Olympian.

[Read more →]

→ 37 CommentsCategories: News
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,